Scott says: "A very frank look at a crime for which a man is sentenced to die, Herzog goes at the whole thing in typical unsentimental fashion. As the case unfolds and we meet killers, families, lawyers and so on, the investigation is really about the American justice system and death row in particular. Although Herzog’s opinions are clear from the very beginning, he allows his film to show all sides of the issue, giving the film balance while allowing a great outpouring of emotion. Strong stuff, but highly recommended for anyone with an interest in what’s going on in the free world."